David Boonin-Vail. In her article, “A Defense of Abortion,” Judith Jarvis Thomson defended the following thesis: the impermissibility of abortion does. David Boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Critically examining a wide range of. Boonin, David, A Defense of Abortion, Cambridge University Press, , pp, $ (pbk), ISBN Reviewed by: Win-chiat Lee.

Author: Yonris Samuzragore
Country: Argentina
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Life
Published (Last): 17 April 2013
Pages: 321
PDF File Size: 7.37 Mb
ePub File Size: 6.82 Mb
ISBN: 869-3-69307-685-5
Downloads: 55007
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Maurn

In other words, one cannot use these criteria to differentiate between abortion and infanticide because they permit both actions. Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web.

For abortuon, it is only because it is possible to save extremely preterm fetuses using advanced medical technology that the question arises about whether the infanticide of fetuses without cortical cortexes is permissible. This is so because one can eliminate this uncertainty about whether or not fetuses in week 20 are conscious by artificially suppressing the emergence of fetal wakefulness altogether.

The first kind focuses on the following difference: What does that say about the boinin of the disconnection in that circumstance? The possibility of infants being born without having been conscious means that they also can be born without having been sentient or having had desires.

Granting that this case is sufficiently analogous to the situation in which a fetus has been diagnosed with Down syndrome—which, for instance, means that it is daivd that the fetus has a right to life—and given that abortoin is impermissible to intentionally secure the death of the violinist, the conclusion follows that abortion in that case would be impermissible.

A Defense of Abortion by David Boonin.

A Defense of Abortion

That is, Boonin owes us an account as to why the duties that are neither based on or correlatives of other people’s rights can never rise to the same level of importance defende seriousness as those that are. But it does not follow that a feminist should conclude that a woman who has an abortion does something that is morally impermissible.


Amazon Restaurants Food delivery from local restaurants. According to this theory, fetuses are ensouled once there is a biological capacity to receive the soul.

The central thesis of philosopher David Boonin is that the moral case against abortion can be shown to be unsuccessful on terms that critics of abortion can and do accept. They had better look elsewhere for the source of the special obligation of the mother and perhaps even the father towards the fetus in non-rape cases to make a case for the moral impermissibility of abortion in such cases.

The author is careful in framing the debate and stresses arguing on an opponent’s own terms. Amazon Second Chance Pass it on, trade it in, give it a second life. This is so because if it were permissible to abort a fetus diagnosed with Down syndrome merely in order to ensure the death of the fetus—as it would be in the first case, where the individual chooses abortion despite the fact that she actually enjoined being pregnant—then it seems hard to defend the position that it would be necessarily impermissible to kill an infant diagnosed with Down syndrome.

However, as I have tried to demonstrate, it might be hard to find external criteria that are able to provide a general justification for the differentiation between fetuses with Down syndrome and unconscious or non-viable bionin. Consequently it seems like anesthetization of the fetus—by which the fetus is prevented from being wakeful—would simply be another obstacle for the ensoulment of the fetus, just as an undeveloped brain constitutes an obstacle for ensoulment according to this view.


My argument is that none of these ways justifies the abortion of fetuses diagnosed with Down syndrome while simultaneously rejecting infanticide. Laura is currently reading it Jun 09, Why should a fetus that is conceived in a rape have fewer rights than a fetus whose parents engage in the intercourse voluntarily but do not care to use contraception?


A background in informal logic and philosophy will certainly be helpful to the reader here. Therefore, if the aim is to avoid becoming a parent of a child with Down syndrome by extinguishing it, infanticide is safer than abortion.

Abortion Ethics Without Metaphysics? There are at least three kinds of associated difficulties. Reproductive Ethics in Applied Ethics.

I hope that it is a good resource for those in the discussion, because it does a much better job than many of the other things that people read around this issue. Cambridge University Press Amazon.

A Defense of Abortion – David Boonin – Google Books

There are no dacid topics on this book yet. The two abovementioned strategies aim to identity a common ground for justifying abortion rights and differentiating abortion and infanticide. Morgan marked it as to-read Jul 14, Kindle Edition Verified Purchase. Amazon Giveaway allows you to run promotional giveaways in order to create buzz, eavid your audience, and attract new followers and customers. If you wish to keep up-to-date on the abortion issue, and know what the best arguments in support of the pro-choice side are, this would be the book to read.

The Ethics of Abortion: